READ · 6 MIN READ

Knowledge Kept for Kings: Who Was Allowed to Read the Sky

Rulers in several eras passed laws about who could read the sky. This page tests one pattern against those laws, shows where it holds and where it breaks, and keeps every grade visible.

This page tests a pattern that comes in two forms. The first says the sky was banned when it could be read about the ruler. The second says the bans came once ordinary people could read the sky. Both are readings, not findings (E2.02, E2.24).

Each claim below carries its row number from the school's notes and a grade in plain words. On record means a source you can open says it. A reading means it is the school's interpretation, not a finding. Open means the sources are missing or disagree.

Mesopotamia: reports for the king

Of 567 Assyrian sky reports in the school's copy, 565 name the king as the one they were written to (E2.04, on record).

Some cuneiform tablets carry a secrecy note saying the text was not to be shown to readers without the right training (E2.05, on record, from a book review).

Whether the main omen series itself carries that note is open (E2.07, open). No Assyrian or Babylonian law against a private person reading the sky was found (E2.08, open).

Rome: private questions banned, the emperor's chart published

In 11 CE Augustus forbade seers to prophesy to a person alone, or about anyone's death. In the same passage he published the stars of his own birth for all to read (E2.09, on record).

In 16 CE the Senate ordered astrologers and magicians expelled from Italy (E2.10, on record).

A law of 357 CE set death by the sword for anyone who consulted an astrologer or a diviner (E2.11, on record). A later law in the same code says learning forbidden things is no lesser fault than teaching them (E2.12, on record).

“The practitioner does not assume all institutions are corrupt. The practitioner assumes all claims require evidence.”

MAGUS: The Ontology of One

China: the sky held by the state

Article 110 of the Tang Code barred private households from holding sky instruments, sky texts, prophecy books and certain calendars. The penalty was two years of penal servitude (E2.13, on record).

A note adds the same penalty for private study of the sky. One old manuscript leaves that line out, and a scholar suspected it was added later (E2.14, on record).

The pope, then paid fortunes

In 1629 an abbot wrote a commentary on past popes. Urban VIII then made it a capital crime to predict the life or death of the sitting pope (E2.16, on record).

The historian who reports it notes that knowing when a leader might die was valuable intelligence (E2.16, on record).

Later laws in England and New York aim at telling fortunes for a fee, framed as fraud. The English Witchcraft Act of 1735 stood until 1951 (E2.18, on record).

New York law, in the text read, makes fortune-telling for a fee a misdemeanor, with an exception for entertainment. Whether bills to repeal it passed was not checked (E2.20, on record).

Where the pattern holds, and where it breaks

In England after 1660, almanacs were published largely free of government interference. A 2017 thesis concludes that the claim of a political attack on astrology does not hold there (E2.21, on record).

The English public kept buying almanacs into the 1700s (E2.22, on record).

One reading of these rows is narrower than either first form. Rulers acted when the sky was read about the ruler, when a person consulted in secret, or when a household held or studied the sky (E2.23, a reading).

In that reading, the ruler kept control of who read the sky about the ruler. Rome shows it plainly: the same emperor who banned private death forecasts published his own chart.

The second form fits Rome and the Tang Code, and it does not fit England after 1660 (E2.24, a reading). Whether the laws came because ordinary people began to read is open (E2.25, open).

“Consensus is not verification. A thousand people believing a thing does not make it lived.”

MAGUS: The Ontology of One

Words used here

On record
A source you can open says it. The grade is for what the source says, not a promise that the source is right.
A reading
The school's interpretation of the record. It is held as a reading and never stated as fact.
Open
Not found, or the sources disagree. An open row is a question, not a claim.
Tang Code
The law code of the Tang dynasty of China, kept with a commentary.
Penal servitude
A sentence of forced labor.

Tonight. Five minutes.

  1. Think of one piece of knowledge you were told is not for you.
  2. Write who said so, and what reason they gave.
  3. Grade the reason: on record, a reading or open.
  4. Write one way you could test that knowledge yourself, with what you have now.

In a week, note whether you tested it, and what your own record shows.

Questions to sit with

  • In your own life, who decides what you are allowed to know?
  • Why might a ruler publish his own chart and ban private readings about death? Keep your answer graded as a reading.
  • Which laws on this page are aimed at fraud, and which at the ruler's safety?

Sources

  • The school's notes, Essay 2, Knowledge Kept for Kings, rows E2.02 to E2.25, written 2026-11-15.
  • Astrological Reports to Assyrian Kings, State Archives of Assyria volume 8, 1992, as counted in the school's copy.
  • A review of Secrecy and the Gods, State Archives of Assyria Studies 19, Journal of Hebrew Scriptures volume 10, 2010.
  • Cassius Dio, Roman History 56.25.5, and Tacitus, Annals 2.32, in the Loeb translations.
  • Codex Theodosianus 9.16.4 and 9.16.8, Latin text. The translations on this page are the school's.
  • The Tang Code with commentary, chapter 9, article 110, Chinese text. The translation on this page is the school's.
  • The dangerous business of predicting the death of popes, TORCH, University of Oxford, 2025.
  • An encyclopedia page on the Witchcraft Act 1735, and New York Penal Law 165.35.
  • The intellectual and social declines of alchemy and astrology, circa 1650 to 1720, doctoral thesis, University of York, 2017.
  • MAGUS: The Ontology of One, Books II and XII, from the school's books.

The quoted lines come from the MAGUS books named under each one. Test it in your own life. Keep what holds.

Go deeper.

Laws are one part of the record. The next page measures how long the whole record is, and what it holds.

The free book is MAGICK, An Introduction.