READ · 6 MIN READ
How Long the Record Is
Astrology's record runs for many centuries. The tests that score it run about forty years. This page measures both and asks the same questions of each, with every grade shown.
This page asks how long astrology's record is, and what that record holds. It holds both sides to one rule of the school: a long record is not graded by its gaps while a short record is graded by its count (E3.04).
Each claim below carries its row number from the school's notes and a grade in plain words. On record means a source you can open says it. A reading means it is the school's interpretation, not a finding. Open means the sources are missing or disagree.
The lengths, measured
The omen series Enuma Anu Enlil was copied from the Old Babylonian period, about 1950 to 1595 BCE, to its latest dated copy in 194 BCE. That is about 1,400 to 1,750 years (E3.05, on record).
The Babylonian Diaries run from 652 to 61 BCE, about 590 years (E3.06, on record). The dated Assyrian reports run about 60 years, in 90 reports (E3.08, on record).
University teaching runs from the early 1300s to the 1680s in some schools, about 380 years (E3.09, on record). The controlled tests run from 1985, about 40 years (E3.10, on record).
One reading of these numbers: kept as a court science or a taught subject, the record runs well over 2,000 years. The tests that score it run about 40 (E3.11, a reading).
What the record holds
Length is one question. What the record holds is a second, and both questions go to each side.
The omens pair a sky sign with a predicted outcome. They are not a log of outcomes that happened (E3.12, on record).
The Diaries write the sky and the prices of goods on the same tablets, so a sky to price comparison can be built from them (E3.13, on record). The school holds 860 monthly price rows from them (E3.07, on record).
Whether anyone has scored the Diaries' sky against their prices is open (E3.14, open). Whether the Assyrian reports note afterward if an omen came true is open too (E3.15, open).
“The tradition's age is not evidence of its accuracy. It is evidence of its cultural fitness”
On the Authority of Experience
One standard, both directions
One reading of the school's rule is that it cuts both ways (E3.17, a reading). A long record is not thrown out for its gaps or its broken tablets. A short record is not thrown out for its small count.
In the same reading, the length of a record is not, alone, a grade of its accuracy. What a record earns depends on what it holds: observations, predictions or scored outcomes.
Applied to the modern side, the tests of 1985 and after tested natal charts against personality. In this reading they keep their grade for what they tested, and they do not reach the timing of events (E3.18, a reading).
Whether the timing of events has been tested with modern statistics is open. No source for that was checked (E3.19, open).
Questions to ask any record
One working list from the school's notes puts four questions to any record. The list is graded as a reading (E3.23).
How long was it kept, from which date to which date? What does it hold: observations, predictions or scored outcomes? How many scored cases are there, and who scored them? Is the same question asked of the other side?
A record strong on the first question and weak on the third is a long record of observation. A record strong on the third and weak on the first is a short record of scoring. Each is named for what it is.
A plain picture helps here. If a shoe hurts after a long walk, the fault may be the size and not the shoe. In one reading, a test that fails on a stranger's chart grades that one fitting (E3.22, a reading).
“The practitioner tests the correlations in their own experience. They retain what produces results. They discard what does not.”
On Astrology: The Recipe for Reality
Words used here
- On record
- A source you can open says it. The grade is for what the source says, not a promise that the source is right.
- A reading
- The school's interpretation of the record. It is held as a reading and never stated as fact.
- Open
- Not found, or the sources disagree. An open row is a question, not a claim.
- Astronomical Diaries
- Babylonian tablets that record the sky next to the weather, the river, prices and events.
- Scored outcome
- A case where someone wrote down what was expected and then checked what happened.
Tonight. Five minutes.
- Pick one practice you keep, of any kind.
- Write how long you have kept it, from which date to which date.
- Write what your record of it holds: notes of what you saw, guesses, or results you checked.
- Count the checked results, and write the number down.
Next week, add any new checked results and see whether the count changed.
Questions to sit with
- Which of your own practices is a long record of observation with few scored cases?
- Where do you grade a long record by its gaps, and a short one by its count?
- What would it take to score one thing you have only observed?
Sources
- The school's notes, Essay 3, How Long the Record Is, rows E3.04 to E3.23, written 2026-11-15.
- The school's checked timeline of sky records, rows 1, 2 and 6.
- Babylonian price data from the Astronomical Diaries, open data under a CC0 licence, doi 10.34894/VJZ5Z9.
- Astrological Reports to Assyrian Kings, State Archives of Assyria volume 8, 1992.
- Astrology and science, an encyclopedia summary page, for the 1985 study.
- The intellectual and social declines of alchemy and astrology, circa 1650 to 1720, doctoral thesis, University of York, 2017.
- On the Authority of Experience and On Astrology: The Recipe for Reality, from the school's books.
The quoted lines come from the MAGUS books named under each one. Test it in your own life. Keep what holds.
Go deeper.
A long record and a short test both reach you as reports. The next page applies one rule to every report, on both sides.
The free book is MAGICK, An Introduction.